The Mushy Middle


    The Mushy Middle

    We look at public opinion about abortion in Texas.

    Norma McCorvey — the “Jane Roe” whose search for a legal abortion led to Roe v. Wade — famously changed her mind about abortion rights. She flipped from being a pro-choice activist in her 30s to a pro-life activist and born-again Christian in her 40s.

    McCorvey led a complex, sometimes tragic life. She suffered physical abuse and struggled with poverty and depression. She also had a habit of telling lies in public, including a false claim of rape and exaggerations about her political views.

    Privately, however, McCorvey was more consistent about her views of abortion rights, as Joshua Prager documents in his recent book — full of revelations — that serves as a dual biography of McCorvey and Roe v. Wade. She was part of what she called “the mushy middle.” Prager writes:

    Who Norma wanted to be was gay and pro-choice — but only moderately pro-choice. Norma no more absolutely opposed Roe than she’d ever absolutely supported it … Norma thus reflected the majoritarian middle ground. She embodied the national ambivalence, the desire for legal yet limited abortion.

    Most Americans believe that abortion should generally be legal early in pregnancies and restricted later. Public opinion has barely moved in decades and is similar across women and men.

    But even if public opinion is stable, abortion policy may be on the verge of major change. The Supreme Court will soon hear two abortion cases — one from Texas, with arguments set for next week; and one from Mississippi, with arguments on Dec. 1. Given the court’s conservative majority, many observers expect it to either overturn Roe or weaken it, freeing states to enact tight abortion restrictions.

    As Prager documents, Texas has been at the center of abortion politics for more than half a century. McCorvey lived in the Dallas area when she sought an abortion in 1969. In response to her lawsuit, a federal court in Texas overturned the state’s abortion law, citing the right to privacy and leading to the landmark Supreme Court case in 1973.

    This year, Texas enacted the country’s most restrictive abortion law, outlawing all abortions after about six weeks of pregnancy. The Supreme Court has let the law stand but also agreed to hear arguments about it.

    I recently asked researchers at Gallup whether they could put together a portrait of public opinion on abortion in Texas. To do so with a large enough sample size, they combined multiple Gallup surveys from the past decade. (That would be a problem on an issue with changing opinions, like marijuana legalization or same-sex marriage, but it’s not a problem with abortion.)

    The results are fascinating. Most Texans are part of that “mushy middle,” saying that abortion should be legal in certain circumstances.

    Source: Gallup

    And below is a breakdown of the middle group — those who said it should legal under certain circumstances. As you can see, many more Texans favor abortion being legal in “only a few” circumstances than in “most” circumstances.

    Source: Gallup

    Still, it is hard to see how Texas’ new law is consistent with the overall views of Texans. The law is stricter. Because many women do not realize they are pregnant until after six weeks, the law bans a vast majority of abortions. Other polls have found that most Americans — and probably most Texans — support widespread access to abortion in the first trimester of pregnancy (which lasts about 12 weeks).

    Jeffrey Jones, a Gallup researcher, told me that abortion views in Texas are close to the average for red states. The state is more pro-choice than parts of the Southeast and more pro-life than much of the Great Plains, as Pew Research Center polls have found.

    If the Supreme Court guts Roe — which guaranteed widespread abortion access in the first trimester — the country’s laws would become even more polarized. Some red states would likely outlaw almost all abortions, while some blue states would have few restrictions.

    That situation might seem as if it would match public opinion, but it wouldn’t. Even in many red states, most voters favor meaningful access to abortion. Even in many blue states, most voters favor meaningful restrictions. In a post-Roe environment, the American public would still be in the “mushy middle,” but relatively few state laws might be.

    Source: Gallup

    Is there any place with a legal framework that more closely matches Americans’ complicated views on abortion? There is: Europe.

    “Most of its nations offer broad access to abortions before 12 weeks or so, and it gets harder to get one after that,” Jon Shields, a government professor at Claremont McKenna College, has written for Times Opinion. Those laws, Shields argued, offered a potential template for an American compromise on the issue, balancing a woman’s right to control her body and a fetus’s right to live.

    Supreme Court justices like to claim that they are simply enforcing constitutional law, but history has shown they are often influenced by public opinion. If they do so again in this case, the polling offers a different, more nuanced picture than many state laws.


    • Conservatives don’t usually cite foreign laws when arguing before the Supreme Court. But abortion is different, The Times’s Adam Liptak has written.

    • President Biden, campaigning for Terry McAuliffe last night, said, “If you want to protect a woman’s right to choose in Virginia, you need a governor absolutely committed to protecting that right.” Here’s the latest Times story on the race.

    • Senate Democrats detailed two proposals to help pay for Biden’s family-policy bill: a corporate minimum tax and a tax on billionaires. (Here’s how they plan to tax the richest of the rich.)

    • Manchin in the middle: Democrats have buttonholed, cajoled and breakfasted with the West Virginia senator to try to secure his vote.

    • The final debate between New York City mayoral candidates Eric Adams and Curtis Sliwa devolved into name-calling.

    Allison Zaucha for The New York Times
    • An F.D.A. panel recommended authorizing the Pfizer vaccine for children 5 to 11. Shots could be available next week.

    • The meeting included a debate about whether children who have had Covid need the vaccine.

    • People with lasting virus symptoms are seeking disability benefits. But the definition of “long Covid” remains unclear.

    • Investigators say the N.H.L.’s Chicago Blackhawks played down a sexual assault accusation in 2010.

    • Haiti is facing a fuel shortage that is pushing it to the brink of collapse.

    • Nine months before Rosa Parks refused to give up her seat, 15-year-old Claudette Colvin did the same. At 82, Colvin is fighting to have her arrest record expunged.

    • The Santa Fe County district attorney is not ruling out criminal charges in the fatal shooting on the set of “Rust.”

    • Atlanta beat Houston, 6-2, in Game 1 of the World Series.

    Russian cyberattacks and Chinese aggression show that America’s global position is crumbling, Bret Stephens argues.

    Accepting that Covid could be with us forever will improve our response, Katherine Eban writes.

    Erik Tanner for The New York Times

    Boo! The secrets behind a great scare.

    Dining: Foodies don’t flock to Midtown Manhattan. They should.

    Never too late: To climb that mountain.

    Trumped: The pandemic forced bridge competitions online. Cheating followed.

    Advice from Wirecutter: Privacy tips for your Android.

    Lives Lived: Mort Sahl revolutionized stand-up comedy, taking an acerbic look at society when other comics were delivering joke-book punch lines. He died at 94.

    Baillie Walsh

    Gimme gimme gimme … another Abba album!

    After 40 years, the Swedish pop group is back with “Voyage,” a new 10-track album. “We took a break in the spring of 1982 and now we’ve decided it’s time to end it,” the band said.

    The popularity of Abba’s music hasn’t waned: “Abba Gold,” a compilation that came out in 1992, is on the British charts more than 1,000 weeks after its release. The musical “Mamma Mia!” — which incorporates Abba’s hits into its story — prompted a number of imitators and two film adaptations. And fans are still obsessed. (On that note, we want to know what Abba’s music means to you.)

    This time around, none of the four band members, who are all in their 70s, will perform in person, Elisabeth Vincentelli writes in The Times. Starting in a custom-built London venue next year, they will perform as avatars — Abbatars — designed to replicate their 1979 look. Here’s one of the new songs, “Just a Notion.” — Claire Moses, a Morning writer

    Christopher Testani for The New York Times

    Mushrooms and black beans are the perfect pairing for a hearty vegetarian chili.

    The pop singer Self Esteem is touching a nerve with honest songs about not having it all figured out.

    “The Chancellor,” Kati Marton’s biography of Angela Merkel, is “a balm,” Dwight Garner writes. “It’s instructive to spend time in Merkel’s competent and humane company.”

    Jimmy Kimmel misses the old Facebook.

    The pangrams from yesterday’s Spelling Bee were curtain and taciturn. Here is today’s puzzle — or you can play online.

    Here’s today’s Mini Crossword, and a clue: “To be,” in Latin (four letters).

    If you’re in the mood to play more, find all our games here.

    Thanks for spending part of your morning with The Times. See you tomorrow. — David

    P.S. As world leaders gather in Glasgow next week, The Times will host the Climate Hub, a forum featuring Greta Thunberg, Al Gore and others.

    Here’s today’s print front page.

    “The Daily” is about Senator Kyrsten Sinema. On “The Argument,” true crime obsession.

    Claire Moses, Ian Prasad Philbrick, Tom Wright-Piersanti, Ashley Wu and Sanam Yar contributed to The Morning. You can reach the team at

    Sign up here to get this newsletter in your inbox.

    Published at Wed, 27 Oct 2021 10:30:13 +0000

    Previous articleNeeded—A Global Approach to Data in the Digital Age
    Next articleMcConnell Endorses Trump Ally Herschel Walker after Months of Establishment Skepticism